heraldalba
  • Home
  • Politics
  • Economy
  • Society
  • Opinion
  • Holyrood
  • International
  • Home
  • Politics
  • Economy
  • Society
  • Opinion
  • Holyrood
  • International
No Result
View All Result
heraldalba
No Result
View All Result
Home Politics

The role of the coronavirus in the Scottish independence referendum process

The Covid-19 outbreak does not support old arguments for Scottish independence. There are two completely opposite scenarios for Scotland's political future. Economic growth or decline is crucial in both scenarios.

Herald Publishers by Herald Publishers
February 1, 2021
in Politics
0
The Protesters set up at border in a bid to keep Scotland coronavirus free

The banner hanging up at the A1 road at the border between Scotland and England with reading "Staycation - Keep Scotland Covid-Free "

The Scottish independence movement seems to have been overshadowed by the outbreak of the coronavirus.
There are two scenarios: the decline of Scottish nationalism or, conversely, the end of the four nations.
The ability of the British or Scottish governments to overcome the dire economic situation caused by the pandemic will determine the future of Scottish independence.

With the outbreak of the coronavirus and its new mutants, a new era of uncertainty and risk has begun that does not support citing old arguments for Scottish independence. No one can predict what the future of the Scottish referendum will look like after the coronavirus! Only two main scenarios can be considered for it.

RelatedPosts

The SNP leadership race: Best leadership candidate to achieve Scottish independence

Yousaf’s Entering Contest for both SNP Leadership and Scotland’s FM

Scotland’s governance right of the Royal Family: Scottish National Party Disobeying Royal Family and London’s Government

Scotland’s future scenarios after the pandemic

Two completely contradictory scenarios can be considered for the future of Scottish independence: The first scenario, based on some predictions, is that after Covid-19, “Scottish nationalism will most likely be pushed back.” But the second scenario, according to other predictions, is quite the opposite, believing that the pandemic could be “the final nail in the coffin of the four nations.”

According to surveys conducted in 2020 after the outbreak, however, neither scenario is feasible, because in the first survey after the outbreak of the disease, little change is seen in this respect and the support for independence remained 46%, support for the union 47%, and 7% still remaining undecided. But even if we accept that coronavirus has not had a sudden impact on how people think about independence, nor changed the financial implications or assessments of how to deal with it, it is likely to play a major role in next May’s elections.

Reasons for the realisation of the first scenario

Reasons behind the decline of Scottish nationalism are based on the “four nations approach” as an example of the benefits of cooperation and union. Those who believe in this view exemplify the financial strength of the British Treasury to fight the virus as compared to the ability of an independent Scotland to do so. They believe that Scotland will not be able to manage financial and economic affairs independently.

Reasons for the realisation of the second scenario

At the same time, there are other reasons for the severe disintegration of the union and the rise of independence sentiments in Scotland since the outbreak. This argument means that Scottish authorities, under limited autonomy, are only responsible for matters such as education. They have no authority in finances and public health. If these important matters are left to an independent Scotland, they will be able to run their own affairs. While the British Government is responsible for immigration, foreign policy and most importantly financial packages to support those who have lost their jobs due to the pandemic. Of course, some other polls support an independent Scottish Government. Of these, 74% say that an independent Scotland can handle the situation well, and only 47% say the same about remaining in the four nations.

Brexit is another factor which has strengthened the prospects of Scottish independence. The Scots are looking to reap the benefits of being in the EU, including the lack of tariffs, the customs union, and easy travel for tourism and trade. Therefore, given Britain’s inability to contain the pandemic and its dire economic consequences, it is very likely that Covid-19 and Brexit will have a growing impact on Scottish independence.

Conservatives support the realisation of the first scenario

Because the Conservatives rule Scotland like an “oligarchic” group, their interests force them to reject the independence referendum. They do not welcome the organisation and mobilisation of the working class for independence. Support for independence in 2010 was about 28%. In 2014, it was 45%. This percentage may increase with the prevalence of the pandemic and its economic consequences. Therefore, 45% support for independence does not seem right. Independence rallies are held but not covered by the media.

The effect of economic growth or decline on the realisation of scenarios

The pandemic raised questions of economic uncertainty for the Scots. Can the North Sea make enough money for Scotland at the time of independence by reducing demand for oil? On the other hand, the pandemic has caused two million British people to lose their jobs, GDP to fall and debt levels to rise. So, this year, it is questionable whether the UK can provide the necessary financial support for Scotland and thus prove its effectiveness to them. At the same time, the cost of advertising in this economic crisis is a serious issue. Is the referendum still approved in these circumstances? The experience of unemployment and anxiety caused by inadequate or inaccessible health services will not be forgotten soon.

 

Under these pressures, Scottish society prioritises health and seeks to address its economic consequences. Under these circumstances, society is unlikely to continue to support the idea of ​​independence. These conditions provide the best opportunity for Conservatives led by Boris Johnson to back down from the decision of a large percentage of independence seekers with populist slogans such as economic efficiency and its combination with values ​​of solidarity, fairness, responsibility, and kindness.

In contrast, the Scottish Government’s relative success in controlling the coronavirus has fuelled nationalist sentiment. Fifty-five percent of Scots voted in favour of independence in a new poll. This pro-independence majority shows that the government, led by Scottish nationalists, has been more successful in controlling the crisis than Boris Johnson and his cabinet.

Therefore, the realisation of any of the above scenarios can be a function of economic efficiency and controlling the consequences of the outbreak. Now, both the Scottish and British governments can persuade voters to affirm or reject independence, whichever is more efficient in these circumstances.

Delay tactics in holding a referendum

Regardless of the Covid-19 pandemic, delays in the Scottish independence referendum are appropriate for those who believe in both scenarios. On the one hand, the delay in the referendum gives the British Government a better opportunity to focus on finalising Brexit and setting its own internal agenda. At the same time, this will be an opportunity for the SNP, so that they can re-evaluate the possibility of their independence post-Brexit. North Sea oil, which forms the basis of their financial capacity for independence, will also be examined.

 

The polls look good for the SNP, indicating that the party stands a good chance of winning next May’s elections by a majority. But the important point is that the polls conducted so far show a serious fluctuation in the process of Scottish independence. The spread of the coronavirus, speed of transmission, economic consequences, and the initiative of governments to control it, will have a significant impact on Scotland’s independence project. Therefore, it cannot be said with certainty that Scotland will gain independence. However, as long as the SNP holds a majority, the probability of an independence scenario is high. Thus, based on voter behaviour in the election, one can understand how Covid-19 plays a role and what effects it has.

How useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate it!

Average rating 0 / 5. Vote count: 0

No votes so far! Be the first to rate this post.

Share this post:

Share on WhatsApp Share on Telegram
Tags: Coronavirusfuture scenariosindependencereferendumScottish national
Herald Publishers

Herald Publishers

Related Posts

snp leadership candidate
Politics

The SNP leadership race: Best leadership candidate to achieve Scottish independence

The Scottish National Party (SNP) has held power in Scotland's devolved parliament since 2007. Following Sturgeon's resignation as first minister,...

by Herald Publishers
March 12, 2023
First Minister of Scotland 2023
Politics

Yousaf’s Entering Contest for both SNP Leadership and Scotland’s FM

The Health Secretary of Scotland announced that he would run for the position of the first minister of the region. The...

by Herald Publishers
March 8, 2023
Londons Government
Politics

Scotland’s governance right of the Royal Family: Scottish National Party Disobeying Royal Family and London’s Government

Can Scottish National Party (SNP) provide a fairer, greener independent economy to help people live happy, healthy, fulfilling lives? Will...

by Herald Publishers
February 21, 2023
Next Post
What is the reason for the Scots protesting against Boris Johnson over vaccination?

Vaccination in Scotland: Scots protest discrimination in vaccination for the coronavirus

Recent opinion polls suggest a majority of Scots now favor independence from the U.K

The SNP Decision for Independence Is More Serious

Scotland’s economy : ten years on from the financial crisis

Brexit’s Impact On Scotland’s Economy

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recommended

Economic

The Negative Economic Effects of Brexit Are Emerging!

2 years ago
Independence referendum: A voice to shape Scotland

Independence referendum: A voice to shape Scotland

4 months ago
Royal Family

Growing Opposition Against the Monarchy in the UK

10 months ago
Ukraine-Russia War

The Economic Consequences of the Ukraine-Russia War on the UK

1 year ago

Categories

  • Economy
  • Holyrood
  • International
  • Opinion
  • Politics
  • Society

Topics

Boris Johnson Brexit britain China Conservative Conservative Party Conservatives Coronavirus cost of living crisis Covid Covid-19 Economic Economy Energy england EU European Union independence Inflation Johnson keir starmer labour Labour Party Liz Truss NATO NHS Nicola Sturgeon Northern Ireland post-Brexit prime minister referendum Rishi Sunak Russia scotland Scottish Scottish Independence Sinn Féin SNP Sturgeon UK UK Government Ukraine US Vladimir Putin Westminster
No Result
View All Result

Highlights

A New Comprehensive Strategy Could Keep Scottish NHS Nurses at Work and Improve Health Service in Scotland

Scotland economy after Brexit: Declining and damaged

Scotland’s governance right of the Royal Family: Scottish National Party Disobeying Royal Family and London’s Government

Scottish Budget changes to benefit and tax system: Resistance against London-caused economic problems

Zero waste Scotland: a review on throwing vape wastes in the environment and the possibilities of facing bans

Scotland’s renewable energy, a card that can be played for Scotland’s independence

Trending

snp leadership candidate
Politics

The SNP leadership race: Best leadership candidate to achieve Scottish independence

by Herald Publishers
March 12, 2023
0

The Scottish National Party (SNP) has held power in Scotland's devolved parliament since 2007. Following Sturgeon's resignation...

First Minister of Scotland 2023

Yousaf’s Entering Contest for both SNP Leadership and Scotland’s FM

March 8, 2023
Westminster Raised Scotland's Budget

Scotland’s Budget Deficit Prevention Strategies: Inward Investments & Inclusive Control over Natural Resources

March 7, 2023
Scottish NHS nurses

A New Comprehensive Strategy Could Keep Scottish NHS Nurses at Work and Improve Health Service in Scotland

February 26, 2023
Scotland economy after Brexit

Scotland economy after Brexit: Declining and damaged

February 22, 2023
heraldalba

We aim to preserve the old and noble values of Scottish society. Protecting the collective identity and national interest of Scotland is our priority.

Recent Posts
  • The SNP leadership race: Best leadership candidate to achieve Scottish independence March 12, 2023
  • Yousaf’s Entering Contest for both SNP Leadership and Scotland’s FM March 8, 2023
  • Scotland’s Budget Deficit Prevention Strategies: Inward Investments & Inclusive Control over Natural Resources March 7, 2023
Categories
  • Economy
  • Holyrood
  • International
  • Opinion
  • Politics
  • Society
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Politics
  • Economy
  • Society
  • Holyrood
  • International