heraldalba
  • Home
  • Politics
  • Economy
  • Society
  • Opinion
  • Holyrood
  • International
  • Home
  • Politics
  • Economy
  • Society
  • Opinion
  • Holyrood
  • International
No Result
View All Result
heraldalba
No Result
View All Result
Home Holyrood

Scottish independence: Tory government tarnish Nicola Sturgeon’s image

Herald Publishers by Herald Publishers
April 9, 2022
in Holyrood, Opinion, Politics
0
Scottish independence

Scottish independence: Tory government tarnish Nicola Sturgeon's image

The Scottish independence process has historically been 300 years old and has been legal since 2010. They link independence to Russia’s interests in Europe and portray the anti-NATO image of Nicola Sturgeon and his party in London’s new media line to tarnish Sturgeon’s image. Last year (months before the Ukraine-Russia war), Sturgeon proposed that Trident nuclear launchers and missile installations be relocated to the Faroe Islands in northern Britain or mainland Britain in the event of independence. This has nothing to do with the Ukraine-Russia war.

Scottish independence agenda

Scotland, which entered a voluntary union with England in 1707, has seen a growing independence movement since the 1970s due partly to the rise of the SNP and dissatisfaction over London’s control of revenue from North Sea oil. Growing demands for the devolution of power from Westminster to Edinburgh led to the creation of the Scottish Parliament in 1999. However, a 2014 referendum on independence from the UK failed after 55 per cent of the Scottish public voted against it. A significant issue in that vote was the desire to stick with the UK’s long-standing membership in the EU rather than secede and apply for EU membership as an independent nation. The 2016 Brexit vote changed that calculus: Scotland’s voters overwhelmingly rejected breaking with the EU, and many view the UK withdrawal as a deep betrayal.

RelatedPosts

Scotland’s renewable energy, a card that can be played for Scotland’s independence

A Special rate should be appointed for buses in Scotland

The Next UK General Election Could See the Failure of the Ban on the Scottish Independence Referendum

The COVID-19 pandemic further spurred support for Scottish independence, which now polls over 50 per cent, because First Minister Nicola Sturgeon’s adept handling of the crisis, which contrasted sharply with London’s mismanagement. Health policy is one of the primary devolved powers, and the Scottish Parliament in Holyrood established separate curfews, lockdowns, and related coronavirus restrictions, competently navigating uncharted waters. This also effectively neutralized another of the arguments against independence from 2014, that the Scottish government cannot operate effectively in a crisis. Demographic trends are also a strong propellant for the independence movement. A 2020 public opinion poll found that over 70 per cent of Scots aged 16–34 support independence.

What were the election results?

Sturgeon vowed to seek a new referendum if pro-independence parties won a majority. And indeed, the SNP, which has led the Scottish Parliament since 2007, achieved a historic fourth-consecutive victory. Though its 64 seats fell short of an outright majority in the 129-seat chamber by 1, it will form a pro-independence alliance with the Scottish Green Party, which controls eight seats. Sturgeon has declared that a fresh referendum is a matter of “when not if.” Still, the first minister will have to navigate a delicate policy landscape to maintain the Scottish Greens’ support, especially on clean energy. And the immediate priority remains steering Scotland’s pandemic recovery, which could work to the advantage of the nationalist movement by giving it time to shore up support ahead of another vote.

Although section 30 of the 1998 Scotland act enables Holyrood to pass legislation traditionally under the jurisdiction of Westminster, including holding an independence referendum, the UK prime minister must first approve the step. Since the devolution, Section 30 orders have been utilized sixteen times, including in 2014, when former British Prime Minister David Cameron entered an agreement with SNP leader Alex Salmond to convene the first independence referendum.

Tory Prime Minister Boris Johnson has indicated that he will deny any request to hold a new referendum. That could prove politically untenable, as many Scots agree with journalist Jamie Maxwell that a Johnson veto would be tantamount to “transforming Britain from a voluntary association based on consent into a compulsory one.” As the SNP’s Michael Russell argued at a 2020 CFR event, “no one has the right to hold the march of a nation. If the people of Scotland say they want a referendum…anybody who is democratic has to accept that that is a right.” However, it could require an unprecedented challenge in the courts to overrule London’s opposition under Section 30.

Who decides whether Scotland should hold an independence referendum?

Scottish First Minister Nicola Sturgeon has demanded a new independence referendum be held in late 2018 or early 2019, once the terms of Britain’s exit from the European Union have become more precise. To do so, she needs authorization from Britain’s parliament, which is sovereign. The Brexit referendum last June called the future of the United Kingdom into question because majorities in England and Wales voted to leave. Still, in Scotland and Northern Ireland, most people voted to stay. Until recently, polls showed that support for independence had barely moved from the 45 per cent who backed it in the 2014 referendum. But polls in the last month have shown support for independence rising.

Scotland joined England in a political union in 1707. While Prime Minister Theresa May’s centre-right Conservative Party has a majority in the UK parliament, it has only one lawmaker in Scotland, and 54 of the 59 Scottish seats are held by Sturgeon’s Scottish National Party (SNP).

Why is the UK government holding back Scottish independence?

The 2014 vote saw 55 per cent opting to stay in the UK, but since Brexit and the COVID-19 pandemic, which has seen the UK suffer a relatively high death rate from the disease, opinion polls suggest support for independence has risen to around 50 per cent. This increases the possibility that if another referendum is held, Scotland will become an independent country again.

The UK would lose eight per cent of its population and around one-third of its landmass and have a significant impact on the UK’s role in the world. The loss of Scotland from the UK, through a democratic process, would be noted around the world. Most people would conclude, understandably, that it would be a diminution of the capacity of the remainder UK to project its interests. Scotland has always had a more significant part in the projection of the image of the UK internationally than its population size would suggest.

Scotland plays a substantial role in the cultural influence of the UK, and Scottish products are a big part of the British brand – losing those would diminish that brand. But I think the most significant impact will be on perceptions of Englishness among the English themselves, who make up 85 per cent of the UK’s population, and the projection of Englishness as a national identity. That identity has been subsumed into British identity for 300 years. Scotland’s departure would train a process of reflection, the outcome of which is complicated to predict but, I think, would have a substantial psychological impact.

Boris Johnson’s government blames Nicola Sturgeon for supporting Russia and calling her anti-NATO leader. The British government is trying to tarnish the image of Sturgeon so that this issue can overshadow the freedom movement in Scotland.

Conclusion

There would, of course, be some damage from the loss of Scottish economic capabilities, such as natural resources and some iconic products, as well as its capacity in the research base and the abilities of the Scottish population. But as a much bigger economy, these losses would be absorbed and would not disrupt the remainder UK’s economy materially over time. The SNP says it wants an independent Scotland to join the EU and much of Scotland’s trade with the rest of the UK is in services not covered by the Brexit agreement between the EU and UK. Scotland also exports energy to the rest of the UK, and so this would need to conform to EU energy policy. As Brexit has shown, such issues could complicate trade and increase the cost of commerce between Scotland and the remainder UK. Now whatever issues the UK government would raise, it would not make any change in attaining independence from Scotland’s Nicola Sturgeon. London’s new media line to defame the image of Sturgeon would not affect the aim of Scotts achieving independence.

How useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate it!

Average rating 0 / 5. Vote count: 0

No votes so far! Be the first to rate this post.

Share this post:

Share on WhatsApp Share on Telegram
Tags: anti-NATOanti-NATO leaderLondon's blameNATONicola SturgeonScottish IndependenceSNP
Herald Publishers

Herald Publishers

Related Posts

Scotlands renewable energy
Economy

Scotland’s renewable energy, a card that can be played for Scotland’s independence

Scotland is an energy rich nation and energy has always been at the forefront of the row for Scotland’s independence....

by Herald Publishers
February 6, 2023
A Special rate should be appointed for buses in Scotland
Politics

A Special rate should be appointed for buses in Scotland

Most of the bus operators, about 130 members, have requested a cap for bus fares at 2 £ for the...

by Herald Publishers
January 17, 2023
The Next UK General Election Could See the Failure of the Ban on the Scottish Independence Referendum
Holyrood

The Next UK General Election Could See the Failure of the Ban on the Scottish Independence Referendum

Is Westminster competent to decide on behalf of the Scots for their future?  What was the outcome of the court's...

by Herald Publishers
December 13, 2022
Next Post
Russia

UK- Russia Diplomacy : Media and information enmity

United Ireland

The Northern Ireland election: Referendum for United Ireland

SNP

Scottish local Council election: SNP performance Referendum

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recommended

Social Care

Social Care: Tax Increases to Save the NHS

1 year ago
United Ireland

The Northern Ireland election: Referendum for United Ireland

10 months ago
democracy

COVID 19: The threats to democracy are increasing

1 year ago
British food threat

British food threat: the alarming rise in hunger

3 months ago

Categories

  • Economy
  • Holyrood
  • International
  • Opinion
  • Politics
  • Society

Topics

Boris Johnson Brexit britain China Conservative Conservative Party Conservatives Coronavirus cost of living crisis Covid Covid-19 Economic Economy Energy england EU European Union independence Inflation Johnson keir starmer labour Labour Party Liz Truss NATO NHS Nicola Sturgeon Northern Ireland post-Brexit prime minister referendum Rishi Sunak Russia scotland Scottish Scottish Independence Sinn Féin SNP Sturgeon UK UK Government Ukraine US Vladimir Putin Westminster
No Result
View All Result

Highlights

what will be the final result of the Online Safety Bill?

The UK Economic Crisis

Charities warn: UK child malnutrition on the rise

Scots oil workers’ protest on Christmas: Violation of workers’ rights

Crimes in Scotland in the last five years: Role of Westminster

Refugee crisis: UK government’s insistence on the implementation of the agreement with Rwanda

Trending

Scotlands renewable energy
Economy

Scotland’s renewable energy, a card that can be played for Scotland’s independence

by Herald Publishers
February 6, 2023
0

Scotland is an energy rich nation and energy has always been at the forefront of the row...

England and Wales's census counts LGBTQ people

England and Wales’s census counts trans and non-binary people for the first time

January 23, 2023
A Special rate should be appointed for buses in Scotland

A Special rate should be appointed for buses in Scotland

January 17, 2023
what will be the final result of the Online Safety Bill?

what will be the final result of the Online Safety Bill?

January 15, 2023
The UK Economic Crisis

The UK Economic Crisis

January 10, 2023
heraldalba

We aim to preserve the old and noble values of Scottish society. Protecting the collective identity and national interest of Scotland is our priority.

Recent Posts
  • Scotland’s renewable energy, a card that can be played for Scotland’s independence February 6, 2023
  • England and Wales’s census counts trans and non-binary people for the first time January 23, 2023
  • A Special rate should be appointed for buses in Scotland January 17, 2023
Categories
  • Economy
  • Holyrood
  • International
  • Opinion
  • Politics
  • Society
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Politics
  • Economy
  • Society
  • Holyrood
  • International